COSTCHECK

Compare Published Water Heater Cost Estimates

Eight sources publish water heater cost data. Their numbers disagree. Below: what each one says, what's included, and why.

$600 – $6,000across 15 published estimates

Range reflects different sources, scopes, and methodologies. Estimates are not directly averaged.

HomeGuideGas Tank · 40 gal
$600 – $1,800
-Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

HomeGuideElectric Tank · 50 gal
$600 – $1,800
-Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

HomeGuideGas Tank · 50 gal
$700 – $2,200
-Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

FixrGas Tank · 50 gal
$800 – $2,500
+Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Aggregates from contractors, material suppliers, and industry data. Uses a standardized cost modeling methodology.

HomeAdvisorGas Tank · 50 gal
$900 – $2,500
+Removal
Source →

Aggregates cost data from homeowner-reported projects and contractor estimates. Ranges represent middle 50% of reported costs.

HomeGuideTankless Gas
$1,500 – $5,000
-Permit+Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

HomeGuideHeat Pump (Hybrid) · 50 gal
$1,500 – $4,000
-Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

HomeAdvisorTankless Gas
$1,800 – $5,000
+Venting+Removal
Source →

Aggregates cost data from homeowner-reported projects and contractor estimates. Ranges represent middle 50% of reported costs.

FixrTankless Gas
$2,000 – $6,000
+Permit+Venting+Removal
Source →

Aggregates from contractors, material suppliers, and industry data. Uses a standardized cost modeling methodology.

Forbes HomeTankless Gas
$2,500 – $5,500

Editorial research combining contractor interviews, aggregator data, and manufacturer pricing.

HomeGuideAll types
$600 – $3,500
-Permit-Venting+Removal
Source →

Collects pricing from contractors and homeowner surveys. Estimates are national averages unless specified.

Forbes HomeAll types
$800 – $3,500

Editorial research combining contractor interviews, aggregator data, and manufacturer pricing.

This Old HouseAll types
$800 – $3,000

Expert-reviewed estimates from contractors and industry professionals.

Bob VilaAll types
$820 – $3,500

Editorial estimates based on contractor interviews, manufacturer data, and regional cost analysis.

HomeAdvisorAll types
$873 – $1,756

Aggregates cost data from homeowner-reported projects and contractor estimates. Ranges represent middle 50% of reported costs.

How we compare sources

We collect published cost estimates from established home-improvement resources and display them with full attribution. Each source uses different data collection methods, scopes, and geographic coverage. We do not average incomparable estimates. Instead, we help you understand what each source includes and why their numbers differ. All sources are linked so you can verify the original data.